Editorial: Just how much is this benefit?

Editorial: Just how much is this benefit? by The Times Union, September 29, 2012
The state hasn’t kept up with dangerous old oil and gas wells.
So how will it keep up with a new gas rush?
The revelation that the state Department of Environmental Conservation isn’t keeping up with inspections of old gas and oil wells would be troubling under any circumstances. Coming at a time when there’s talk of DEC taking on far more work to keep tabs on fracking deepens our concern. The finding by The Associated Press that thousands of potentially problematic wells remain unaddressed highlights some of the key unanswered questions in the debate over high-volume horizontal hydraulic fracturing: How will an agency that has been decimated by staff cuts keep up with a veritable gas rush in New York? How much will it cost, and who will pay the tab? And, long after the wells have run dry, who will be responsible for them? We’re hard pressed to see how the DEC, as it stands now, would be up to the task of monitoring what is expected to be thousands of new wells if fracking is allowed. As an AP review of the state’s own records showed, about 4,800 unplugged, abandoned wells have been identified in the state, and estimates are that an equal number have yet to be found. These “orphan” wells were abandoned, presumably, by drillers who got what they wanted from them and left the cleanup for society. Neglect of the wells, along with waste pits and storage tanks, has led to of oil and contaminated brine leaking into residential water wells and streams. The DEC says these orphan wells are a relic of an era before modern regulation. More drilling actually would help cure the problems, the agency maintains, since regulations now under development in anticipation of fracking would require drillers to cap any old wells they find within a mile of theirs. So, the argument goes, the same industry that dumped this problem on the state will now fix it. And making sure it does will be a short-staffed agency that hasn’t been able to track down and deal with these old wells for decades — and which would also have thousands of new horizontal wells to monitor. Clearly, that’s unrealistic. DEC will need to grow if this is to be done right — unless, of course, the state wants to follow the lead of Pennsylvania, which has been simply ignoring some other crucial environmental regulation in a vain effort to keep on top of fracking. We’ve heard a lot from the industry and its boosters about what an economic development boon fracking would be for New York. Maybe so. … So here’s what New York state ought to say to those would-be drillers: Our taxpayers will not pay for the privilege of letting someone else make money.

This entry was posted in Global Frac News. Bookmark the permalink.