Anadarko Petroleum settles pollution clean-up case for $5.15bn, Largest ever settlement for environmental contamination reached over cleanup of thousands of sites tainted with hazardous chemicals by Associated Press, April 3, 2014, The Guardian
The US initially sought $25bn to clean up decades of contamination at dozens of sites. The bulk of the money – $4.4bn – will pay for environmental cleanup and be used to settle claims stemming from the legacy contamination.
The company, rather than pay for the environmental mess it created, decided to shift the liabilities between 2002 and 2006 into Tronox. Kerr-McGee, meanwhile, kept its valuable oil and gas assets. [Is that what Encana did, when it split off its oil riches into Cenovus in 2009 after being served legal papers in the Ernst v. Encana lawsuit? How many other contamination cases were/are there against Encana? How many settled with gag orders?]
“Kerr-McGee’s businesses all over this country left significant, lasting environmental damage in their wake,” said Deputy Attorney General James Cole. “It tried to shed its responsibility for this environmental damage and stick the United States with the huge cleanup bill.” [It appears citizens and individuals are still stuck with a massive bill, eg, 19 Billion – 5 Billion = 14 Billion clean up costs not covered by this settlement]
The settlement releases Anadarko from all claims against Kerr-McGee. “This settlement … eliminates the uncertainty this dispute has created, and the proceeds will fund [some of] the remediation and cleanup of the legacy environmental liabilities,” said Anadarko CEO Al Walker.
The settlement funds will be paid into a trust that covers cleanup of contaminated sites in 22 states and the Navajo Nation. Among the dozens of locations targeted for cleanup under the settlement is a former chemical manufacturing site in Nevada that has led to contamination in Lake Mead, abandoned uranium mines in and around the Navajo Nation, and a Superfund site in Gloucester, New Jersey, polluted by thorium.
The US initially sought $25bn to clean up decades of contamination at dozens of sites. A US bankruptcy judge in New York in December found Kerr-McGee had improperly shifted its environmental liabilities to Tronox and should pay between $5.15bn and $14.2bn, plus attorney’s fees. Cole said at a news conference Thursday that the government decided that the $5.15bn amount was more than enough to cover the damages. [Or caved, as is most often the case with settlements out of court] “It provides us with recovery now as opposed to years and years down the road,” he said.
After the settlement’s announcement, Anadarko’s stock rose 15%, to $99.43. [Emphasis added]
Anadarko Petroleum settles U.S.-wide clean-up case for $5.15 billion by Nick Brown with additional reporting by Julia Edwards, Ayesha Roscoe and David Ingram in Washington, D.C. and Terry Wade and Anna Driver in Houston; Editing by Tom Hals in Wilmington, Delaware and Grant McCool, April 3, 2014, Reuters
Energy company Anadarko Petroleum Corp agreed on Thursday to pay more than $5 billion to clean up areas across the United States polluted by nuclear fuel, wood creosote and rocket fuel waste that caused cancer and other health problems. The agreement resolves a long-running lawsuit against the Kerr-McGee energy and chemical company, which Anadarko bought in 2006. The case was brought by a trust representing the U.S. government, 11 state governments, Indian tribes and individuals.
The trust was seeking cleanup costs at more than 2,000 sites nationwide. It was also seeking payment for claims from more than 8,000 people who said their exposure to Kerr-McGee’s wood treatment plants in Avoca, Pennsylvania and Manville, New Jersey caused cancer, which in some cases led to death. “If you are responsible for 85 years of poisoning the earth, you are responsible for cleaning it up,” the U.S. Attorney for Manhattan, Preet Bharara, said at a news conference announcing the settlement.
Despite the size of the settlement, investors cheered, boosting Anadarko’s share price 14.5 percent to $99.02 per share. Analysts said the company was facing the possibility of having to pay a much higher price. “This is a premier exploration company that has this dark cloud hanging over them and now its gone,” said Fadel Gheit, oil analyst at Oppenhemier. Anadarko had argued the environmental liabilities belonged to Tronox Ltd, a paint and chemicals company that was spun off from Kerr-McGee. The sale of Tronox, which ultimately fell into bankruptcy, happened before Anadarko’s purchase.
In December, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Allan Gropper of New York said Kerr-McGee knew the spin-off would harm Tronox’s business by weighing it with heavy environmental liabilities. He said Anadarko should pay from $5.15 billion to more than $14 billion in cleanup costs. Anadarko said after the ruling the liabilities should be as little as $850 million. Tronox, which makes titanium dioxide used in paints, said in a statement that the accord means “the cleanup of the Kerr-McGee legacy environmental damages can begin and people injured by those actions can finally be compensated.”
At one point Kerr-McGee gave Tronox control of a nuclear fuel plant in Oklahoma, where activist worker Karen Silkwood had been employed years earlier. Meryl Streep portrayed her in the eponymous 1983 film about her fight to improve workers’ safety before her death in a car accident. The settlement with Anadarko is the largest environmental enforcement settlement ever by the Department of Justice, larger even than its plea agreement with BP over its massive 2010 Gulf oil spill, which resulted in $4 billion in criminal fines for the British company.
The lawsuits blamed Kerr-McGee’s use of coal tar creosote, which the Environmental Protection Agency has said is a probable cause of cancer. Another troublesome operation was Kerr-McGee’s decades-old jet and rocket fuel manufacturing plant in Henderson, Nevada, where ammonium perchlorate, a primary fuel component, penetrated soil and then groundwater, causing potential harm to people in Nevada, California and Arizona.
Anadarko said in a statement that it would record a net $550 million tax benefit from the agreement. “This settlement agreement with the Litigation Trust and the U.S. Government eliminates the uncertainty this dispute has created,” Anadarko Chief Executive Officer Al Walker said.
A Department of Justice source who asked not to be identified said “Anadarko was not found to have done anything wrong.”
The $5.15 billion settlement will fund a wide array of projects, including $1.1 billion to address the perchlorate contamination in Nevada, the litigation trust said in a statement. The Navajo Nation will get about $1 billion to address radioactive contamination from Kerr-McGee’s decades-old uranium mining operation. Another $1.1 billion will go toward cleanup at more than two dozen contaminated sites around the country. Tronox used its Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection case to shed the environmental liabilities it had inherited in the spinoff by assigning them to a litigation trust. It emerged from bankruptcy in 2011. The trust in turn sued Anadarko and Kerr-McGee, arguing the spinoff was a fraudulent ploy by Kerr-McGee to offload its clean-up responsibilities and make itself a more valuable takeover target for Anadarko, and that it doomed Tronox by loading it up with too much liability. U.S. Attorney Bharara said Kerr-McGee had tried to avoid the cleanup “through a corporate shell game.” [Emphasis added]
Click on image from Wikipedia, for more information on Karen Silkwood