U of C must obey Charter when disciplining students, rules court, Case relates to students who criticized instructor on Facebook in 2007 by Daryl Slade, May 9, 2012, Calgary Herald
The province’s top court has dismissed the University of Calgary’s appeal for autonomy in disciplining students for non-academic conduct. Alberta Court of Appeal, in its written decision released on Wednesday, concluded the Charter of Rights and Freedoms should apply in such situations. It upheld a judicial review by a Court of Queen’s Bench ruling that found the school infringed upon the freedom of expression of twin brothers Keith and Steven Pridgen, 22, when it sanctioned them for criticizing their professor on Facebook. “The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms applies to the disciplinary proceedings undertaken by the university,” Justice Marina Paperny wrote in the unanimous decision. “The decision of the Review Committee failed to take into account the Pridgens’ right to freedom of expression under the Charter. The decision breached the Pridgens’ freedom of expression and cannot be saved by the Charter. Moreover, the Review Committees’ decision was unreasonable from an administrative law perspective. The decision of the chambers judge to quash the Review Committee’s decision is upheld and the appeal of the university is dismissed.” Justices Bruce McDonald and Brian O’Ferrall agreed. … “Given the prolonged and protracted history of this unfortunate matter, I decline to exercise our jurisdiction to refer these matters back to the Board, which after all had wrongly declined to hear the respondents’ (Pridgens’) appeals in the initial instance,”
-
Recent Posts
- New study: Plastics, a “self-reinforcing” petroleum pollution feedback loop: Rapid degradation in warmer temperatures, demands frequent replacement, further contributing to greenhouse gas emissions. “Typically viewed as unrelated problems, global warming and plastic pollution are instead inextricably trapped in a ‘vicious circle’ where one feeds the other.” March 28, 2024
- California (non regulator of destructive industries like Alberta): Chevron – “one of the state’s most prolific polluters” – to pay $13Million (peanuts for a $multibillion profit-raping company) in fines after profiting from illegal spills, some decadeslong and which remain ongoing. I bet Chevron won’t pay; there’s no enforcer, why waste money? March 26, 2024
- 2024 03 22: Rest in Peace Dr. Eilish Cleary. Thank you for warning us of the dangers of glyphosate and frac’ing when you were New Brunswick’s chief medical officer of health. It remains unforgivable the gov’t tried to silence you, and trashed you for telling the truth. March 25, 2024
- Bravo! Excellent humane ruling on our right to medical assistance in dying (MAID). Justice Feasby: “The harm to M.V. if an injunction is granted goes to the core of her being. The choice to live or die with dignity is MV’s alone to make.” March 25, 2024
- This. Is. Why. Judges. Lawyers. Enable. Rape. “Words expressing support for gender equality are cheaper than membership of the Garrick” Club. Roll-call of Britain’s man cave club, which bars women, includes judges, barristers and ministers March 25, 2024
- About fucking time, after letting the slaughter of kids, women, journalists, doctors, nurses, aid workers, first responders, professors, deans, dancers, artists, musicians, poets, sports pros and more innocents go on and on (watched by the world), UN Security Council demands immediate ceasefire in Gaza (but only until April 9). USA, Israel’s genocide financier, abstains. Hey racist Zionists (that includes you Rosalie Abella): Palestinians are not insects, they are not dogs, they are human and have rights to their own homes, lands, olive groves and farms, water, oil and gas; they deserve and need *permanent* peace. March 25, 2024
- Overlooked feedback loop: As fossil fools frac Alberta to dried up hell, drought causes soils to crack, releasing more CO2 and other greenhouse gases, escalating climate chaos. March 24, 2024
- Cruel hide-in-the-closet misogynistic hateful old white man fascist Steve Harper to be appointed minister of foreign affairs under Pierre Picklehead? March 23, 2024
- Brian Mulroney: Cruel to Indigenous, cruel to women, cruel to workers, cruel to ordinary Canadians, cruel to Canada. March 22, 2024
- Human pollution (and over breeding) is taking the breath of trees away: “Trees in warmer, drier climates are essentially coughing instead of breathing,” sending CO2 right back into the atmosphere so they no longer serve as solution to our carbon pollution while earth continues heating and humans continue making more carbon pollution. Stupidest species on earth. March 22, 2024
- The Beaverton: In honour of Mulroney, national funeral to be privatized March 22, 2024
- Southern Alberta en route to waterless Hell March 21, 2024
- 2024 Canadian Hillman Prize winner: “Killer Water,” a story of greed, corruption, and willful government neglect. Congratulations Brandi Morin, Geordie Day, Ricochet Media/The Real News Network/IndigiNews Media and team, and Fort Chip community! March 19, 2024
- Alberta, The Wild Wild West of Stupid: Under extreme drought and climate chaos diminishing supplies, frac’ers plan to truck water province-wide March 19, 2024
- Alberta rural municipalities want “No Duty of Care” AER – industry’s self-regulating servant, to make oil and gas companies pay their taxes (over $250 Million owed and growing). Will a delinquent multi billion dollar profit-raping industry make itself pay its debts as it wipes out earth’s livability? Not even in your dreams. March 19, 2024