CONSTITUTION Why this year could prove to be the Charters most controversial by Kirk Makin, April 15, 2012, The Globe and Mail
Created 30 years ago amid immense political controversy, the Charter of Rights and Freedoms could easily have become an empty shell. Instead, its guarantees of liberty, equality and fairness have permeated political life and Canadian cultural consciousness. Yet, for all the contentious issues it has settled, the Charter is poised to become more relevant than ever. A federal government with an ambitious agenda of reform is running headlong toward the one institution that has the power to send it back to the drafting board – the judiciary. … And a wave of new challenges is surging forward, including to mandatory minimum sentences, electronic surveillance and enhanced police powers. Prime Minister Stephen Harper may not face strong opposition in Parliament or from the provinces, but his policies are brushing up against more core legal roadblocks than any of his predecessors faced. Many legal experts believe that the Charter could be used to block mandatory minimum sentences, a crackdown on refugees and measures that will pack more inmates into already-overcrowded prisons. … With lower-court judges starting to dismantle some legislation, the burning question becomes: What will the Supreme Court of Canada do? … “Already, there are signs of pushback from the courts,” said law professor Jamie Cameron, of York University’s Osgoode Hall Law School. “It’s no secret that the Harper government is determined to test the limits of its power, for example, with criminal law, refugee law and Internet surveillance.” The government’s biggest courtroom loss came last fall, when the Supreme Court of Canada ordered it to keep its hands off of Insite, a supervised drug-injection clinic in Vancouver. The decision reverberated through the judiciary; serving for many judges as a sign from the top that it will act boldly when a situation warrants it. … When a judge finds that a Charter guarantee has been violated, the government is then compelled to show that the breach is “justifiable in a free and democratic society.” The key yardsticks in this analysis are whether the goal of the law was important enough to justify breaching a Charter right and whether less intrusive ways of achieving the same goal were available. After 30 years and hundreds of cases, some decidedly elastic concepts have also been added to the mix – such as whether the law was “arbitrary” or “grossly disproportionate” to the government’s goal. The next laws in line to fall may be some of the mandatory minimum sentences contained in a recent omnibus bill – Bill C-10. Queen’s University law professor Donald Stuart predicted that among the first to go could be a mandatory minimum sentence for growing as few as five marijuana plants. Echoing a widely held view in the legal community, Prof. Stuart argued the provision is so “simplistic and ridiculous” that it could cause the courts to breathe life into a little-used Charter guarantee against cruel and unusual punishment. [Emphasis added]
-
Recent Posts
- Zionistiche Gestapo ‘n B’nai Brith bribing bigot con MPP Ted Arnott and Doug Ford? Discrimination and racism on steroids: Speaker Arnott pisses on Canada’s charter, bans Palestinian Keffiyehs from Ontario legislature. Yarmulke allowed? “Heaven forbid someone make a political statement in a …. legislature” April 17, 2024
- Humans increasing CO2 is driving increase in worldwide severity and frequency of wildfires; “The best way to decrease wildfires is to mitigate our carbon dioxide emissions. We need more emission control now.” April 17, 2024
- Humanity’s polluted planet creating plastic-brained zombies? April 17, 2024
- Alberta: TC Energy’s Nova Gas Transmission Line explodes, starts out of control wildfire by Edson. But but but, Premier Danielle Smith insists arsonists start wildfires: “Trudeau! Trudeau!” April 16, 2024
- Sulfolane, health-harming sour gas sweetener, used *intentionally* for decades by oil and gas industry, found in groundwater in “large contaminant plumes across Canada, specifically in Alberta.” Companies *intentionally* dumped it into aquifers with families and cattle poisoned, bullied and *intentionally* gagged by lawyers years ago. Now researchers say it’s emerging and accidental. FFS. April 16, 2024
- USA finally regulates deadly Silica Dust; long-awaited rule will limit worker exposure, which can lead to incurable, debilitating lung disease. *But* rule is delayed 1 year for coal, 2 years for metal/nonmetal miners. (Will oil and gas be exempt?) April 16, 2024
- Alberta under fascist Danielle Smith and her anti-science, anti-education, anti-health, anti-freedom, misogynistic TBA evangelicals & oil, frac and gas. April 14, 2024
- Arrakis in Frac’d West Texas April 14, 2024
- FFS Trudeau! Iran is defending itself from a murderous war criminal. Do not include me in your “we.” I do not stand with lying genocidal terrorists, occupier Israel or thieving Zionism, no matter what lies ‘n spin Rosalie Abella, B’nai Brith, Irwin Cotler and media spew. April 14, 2024
- Cowardly Crime-enabling Genocidal Canadian Courts: supreme court pisses on Blood Tribe in nauseating ruling by J O’Bonsawin, its one Indigenous judge, writing reconciliation is about “helping to restore the honour of the Crown” not reconciling. WTF! No justice for Indigenous, just stinky judicial circle jerking. April 13, 2024
- The Economist: “Israel has lost the battle for global public opinion.” The Court of Public Opinion is the most powerful court in the world, it sees Zionism’s genocide, terrorism and killing Freedom of Expression everywhere (trying to hide it). April 13, 2024
- Bribed to enable Genocide. The world needs to criminalize Zionism (and frac’ing) and boycott Israel & USA (& Germany & UK & Canada …) April 13, 2024
- BDS Victory! Canada’s first Faculty Association votes to divest “from any companies and investments complicit in Israeli war crimes or illegal occupation.” What ever will the Zionistiche Gestapo and B’nai Brith do? April 12, 2024
- 1,122 Indigenous persons/groups globally sign in solidarity with Palestine: “Stop the Genocide. End the Siege. End the Occupation. Dismantle Apartheid. Decolonize Palestine.” April 12, 2024
- “Disappointing” supremely racist court of Canada ex-justice Rosalie Abella, in tandem with past Attorney General Irwin Cotler, fellow Zionist, “slyly” enables Israel’s genocide of Palestinians. April 11, 2024