Chesapeake: From Bad to Worse to Potentially Criminal by Brian Stoffel, June 25, 2012, The Motley Fool
Imagine this: In May of 2010, the Michigan Department of Natural Resources held land auctions that drew particular interest from natural gas companies hoping to frack the state’s Collingwood shale. The auction of 118,000 acres brought in a whopping $178 million for the state. A full 83% of bids had competitive offers, and Chesapeake and Encana combined to contribute 93% of the sales to the state. Just five months later, Michigan held a similar land auction. This time, more than twice as many acres were up for sale. The result? The state brought in a paltry $9.7 million. Whereas land went for about $1,500 per acre in May, it sold for just $35 per acre in October. It probably didn’t help that natural gas prices had fallen 20% in the interim, but that hardly explains the full extent of a 98% drop in land price. Even before the October auction, a contractor hired by Chesapeake to bid for land noted that both companies had cut their maximum per acre bids by 50%. This led the contractor to question the company if this was just a “coincidence.” Though the contractor never got an official answer to his question, emails reveal that it may not have been a coincidence at all. … Colluding with a competitor to hold prices down for land would be in direct violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act and carry stiff penalties. Companies could be fined up to $100 million — and individuals $1 million — for each offense. Additionally, victims of the rigging can receive up to triple what they missed out on. Though it is common practice to have joint ventures and area-of-mutual interest agreements between competing companies, it does not appear that either one of these mechanisms was in place during the October bidding. Instead, it seems that the companies divvied up counties to lower competition. Emails reveal that the two companies evenly divided bidding in certain counties. In the end, neither company abided by the agreement 100%, but neither company bought land in the same county as the other. … It could take months or years for this to play out in court, but the markets need not wait to factor in such risks. Chesapeake has already been plagued by bad behavior from McClendon, ranging from leveraged bets that exposed him to conflicts of interest to running a secret hedge fund with current SandRidge Energy (NYS: SD) CEO Tom Ward. I wouldn’t be surprised to see McClendon shown the door soon at Chesapeake. For Encana, one of Canada’s largest natural gas companies, it’s more difficult to see how things will play out. [Emphasis added]
Recent Posts
- “Unwelcome Guests.” Alberta’s Danielle Smith & her “100-person convoy of oil crony delegates” at COP28 December 2, 2023
- Murderous Fuck Henry Kissinger’s Obit November 30, 2023
- If men could get pregnant, … November 30, 2023
- Killer Water: The toxic legacy of Canada’s oil sands industry for Indigenous communities. Complete documentary November 29, 2023
- Excellent quote on AER by Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation Chief Allan Adam: “I would like the (regulator) to immediately cease what they’re doing…They’re not credible enough to do anything.” November 27, 2023
- “NDP, go frack free,” chant 250 citizens outside BC 2023 New Democratic Party convention in Victoria; Resolution to end fracking sponsored by 14 electoral district associations did not reach the floor, as usual. November 20, 2023
- Frac’ing harms seniors. UC Berkeley epidemiologist David González: best way to protect health is by eliminating the hazard — ban new wells and phase out existing fossil fuel development. Frac’d resident Ray Kemble: “This industry is basically killing us” November 18, 2023
- Alberta: Methane leaks still leaking more than official estimates (of course), threatening life on earth; UCP led by “Take Back Alberta” Extreme Right Anti-Science Anti-Earth Religious Party (TBA) and AER still lying, letting companies avoid clean up (more than $300B in liabilities). UCP/TBA solution? Ban wind and solar. November 16, 2023
- Hayes Carll: “This is why your whole world is on fire…why you can’t drink from your own springs.” November 16, 2023
- New study: Frac compressor pollution harms health. Dear Encana/Ovintiv/Lynx/AER/UCP & TBA et al: Shut up frac compressors and stop poisoning us, our loved ones, homes, livestock, wildlife; stop harming our health! November 15, 2023
- CEOs: Easily replaced with AI, or more fairly (i.e. not old rich white man biased) and law-abiding, a mop. May as well automate politicians too. November 15, 2023
- Racist Canada shits on Remembrance Day, votes *for* Israel’s illegal settlements taken by military force on Palestinian lands; Doctors without Borders reports sniper shooting patients inside Gaza hospital. November 12, 2023
- Frac Compendium 9: From 65 studies to “an avalanche” of nearly 2,500 showing evidence of harm from frac’ing. Dr. Sandra Steingraber: “Fracking resembles lead paint or indoor smoking — no rules or regulations can make these practices safe.” November 12, 2023
- Frac’ing ‘generation 3’ rock requires injecting captured carbon to make more oil flow. No wonder companies, lobby groups, regulators, gov’ts and Env NGOs are conning the world with Net Zero miracles via high risk Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS). November 9, 2023
- Texas: Sound Resources Solutions chemical explosion injures at least one worker; highly flammable toxic products used/made at the plant include: xylene, toluene, acetone, methy ethyl ketone, phosphoric acid, acetic acid, sulfuric acid 93, various isoproply alcohols, hexane, etc. Residents within 5 mile radius ordered to shelter in place and turn off HVAC systems. Homes, schools, hospitals, workplaces will not be able to keep toxic chemical fumes out. November 8, 2023