Chesapeake: From Bad to Worse to Potentially Criminal by Brian Stoffel, June 25, 2012, The Motley Fool
Imagine this: In May of 2010, the Michigan Department of Natural Resources held land auctions that drew particular interest from natural gas companies hoping to frack the state’s Collingwood shale. The auction of 118,000 acres brought in a whopping $178 million for the state. A full 83% of bids had competitive offers, and Chesapeake and Encana combined to contribute 93% of the sales to the state. Just five months later, Michigan held a similar land auction. This time, more than twice as many acres were up for sale. The result? The state brought in a paltry $9.7 million. Whereas land went for about $1,500 per acre in May, it sold for just $35 per acre in October. It probably didn’t help that natural gas prices had fallen 20% in the interim, but that hardly explains the full extent of a 98% drop in land price. Even before the October auction, a contractor hired by Chesapeake to bid for land noted that both companies had cut their maximum per acre bids by 50%. This led the contractor to question the company if this was just a “coincidence.” Though the contractor never got an official answer to his question, emails reveal that it may not have been a coincidence at all. … Colluding with a competitor to hold prices down for land would be in direct violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act and carry stiff penalties. Companies could be fined up to $100 million — and individuals $1 million — for each offense. Additionally, victims of the rigging can receive up to triple what they missed out on. Though it is common practice to have joint ventures and area-of-mutual interest agreements between competing companies, it does not appear that either one of these mechanisms was in place during the October bidding. Instead, it seems that the companies divvied up counties to lower competition. Emails reveal that the two companies evenly divided bidding in certain counties. In the end, neither company abided by the agreement 100%, but neither company bought land in the same county as the other. … It could take months or years for this to play out in court, but the markets need not wait to factor in such risks. Chesapeake has already been plagued by bad behavior from McClendon, ranging from leveraged bets that exposed him to conflicts of interest to running a secret hedge fund with current SandRidge Energy (NYS: SD) CEO Tom Ward. I wouldn’t be surprised to see McClendon shown the door soon at Chesapeake. For Encana, one of Canada’s largest natural gas companies, it’s more difficult to see how things will play out. [Emphasis added]
-
Recent Posts
- New study: Glyphosate is generated from additives (aminopolyphosphonates) used in European (but not USA) detergents in presence of manganese in treated wastewater. “Ecologists are warning of incalculable consequences.” May 17, 2025
- The Day America Died: Brain dead Georgia law makers force a dying baby to suffer for months in its mother, a corpse incubator. Repuglican “loving” Christianity teaches them to hate, rape and abuse women and girls while worshipping the unborn. My condolences to the family being tortured by these evil goons. May 16, 2025
- Review of 373 studies: “Among the 22 viruses for which we found evidence for detection in the semen following acute infection, nine had published evidence for sexual transmission as well.” May 16, 2025
- PA frac lawsuit (aka walk through hell): Big win for Brian Latkanich and his lawyer Lisa Johnson. Judge Lucas overruled Chevron seeking to be removed from the case, keeping it a defendant. May 15, 2025
- Again, CBC fails to report that PFAS “Forever Chemicals” (not yet regulated in Canada, FFS) are injected in frac’s by oil and gas companies. May 15, 2025
- Ben Cohen (co-founder of Ben & Jerry’s): “You are killing poor kids in Gaza and paying for it by cutting MEDICAID for kids here.” Thank you Mr. Cohen, you have more courage, integrity and honour than all USA Repuglicans and Democrats combined. Diane Russell: “Not all heroes wear capes. Some make great ice cream and Good Trouble.” May 14, 2025
- Killer Douche Fuckers! Jan 1, 2026, Georgia USA enables cancer by Roundup/glyphosate weed killer and much more; protects pesticide makers from some cancer lawsuits. What about brain damage? May 14, 2025
- Piperacillin may offer less harmful treatment for the escalating problem of Lyme disease (caused by Borrelia burgdorferi, spread by black-legged ticks) which can result in severe disease if not treated properly. May 14, 2025
- “Is he dead yet?” asked Piglet? “No,” said Poo. “Fuck,” said Piglet. And more by Sweary History with James Fell. May 14, 2025
- Tap Water: A Toxic Brew? Quebec study found 50 different kinds of pesticides and metabolites, including brain damaging carcinogen glyphosate. May 13, 2025
- New study: Gas stoves double kids’ cancer risk from benzene exposure. Dear CAPP, “Natural Gas” needs to be renamed “Poisonous Gas.” It’s been known for decades that gas harms our health, yet companies, regulators, politicians and you keep pimping toxic gas as green and clean, killing us and our kids, never mind the devastating harm it’s doing to our aquifers, atmosphere and climate. May 11, 2025
- Israel’s genocide: Microsoft has “blood on their hands” and jury awards massive $167M in punitive damages against spyware company NSO Group (made Pegasus spyware). May 11, 2025
- John Cusack: “Gaza is being annihilated. Thousands upon thousands of children are dead. Entire bloodlines erased. … And don’t dare hide behind antisemitism … using it to silence truth while bombs fall on children is a grotesque betrayal of every moral code.” May 11, 2025
- New Film “Under Pressure” exposes deadly dangers of CO2 pipelines supplying oil and gas industry’s Carbon Capture *Scam* (increases pollution, leaks, fails and costs $billions more than promised) that politicians, including Canada’s PM Mark Carney, allow and worse, gift with $billions from taxpayers. “If you don’t sign an easement, we’re going to take it and give it to the pipeline people.” May 9, 2025
- New study: All but 3 of America’s 28 biggest cities are sinking from pumping out too much groundwater May 9, 2025