Must Read, especially for Albertans: Stephen Harper’s Closing of the Canadian Mind in The New York Times

The Closing of the Canadian Mind by Stephen Marche, August 14, 2015 (August 16, print edition), The New York Times

2015 08 16 New York Times, Harper closing the Canadian Mind, 16marche-master675

Stephen Harper, the prime minister of Canada, is creating a legacy of secrecy and ignorance. Credit Mark Blinch/Reuters

canadian shame

Canadian Shame

THE prime minister of Canada, Stephen Harper, has called an election for Oct. 19, but he doesn’t want anyone to talk about it.

He has chosen not to participate in the traditional series of debates on national television, confronting his opponents in quieter, less public venues, like the scholarly Munk Debates and CPAC, Canada’s equivalent of CSPAN. His own campaign events were subject to gag orders until a public outcry forced him to rescind the forced silence of his supporters.

Mr. Harper’s campaign for re-election has so far been utterly consistent with the personality trait that has defined his tenure as prime minister: his peculiar hatred for sharing information.



Americans have traditionally looked to Canada as a liberal haven, with gun control, universal health care and good public education.

But the nine and half years of Mr. Harper’s tenure have seen the slow-motion erosion of that reputation for open, responsible government. His stance has been a know-nothing conservatism, applied broadly and effectively. He has consistently limited the capacity of the public to understand what its government is doing, cloaking himself and his Conservative Party in an entitled secrecy, and the country in ignorance.


His relationship to the press is one of outright hostility. At his notoriously brief news conferences, his handlers vet every journalist, picking and choosing who can ask questions. In the usual give-and-take between press and politicians, the hurly-burly of any healthy democracy, he has simply removed the give.

harper_science cut

Mr. Harper’s war against science has been even more damaging to the capacity of Canadians to know what their government is doing. The prime minister’s base of support is Alberta, a western province financially dependent on the oil industry, and he has been dedicated to protecting petrochemical companies from having their feelings hurt by any inconvenient research.

2015 02 18 Harper's CSIS RCMP have Mother Nature under surveillance

In 2012, he tried to defund government research centers in the High Arctic, and placed Canadian environmental scientists under gag orders. That year, National Research Council members were barred from discussing their work on snowfall with the media. Scientists for the governmental agency Environment Canada, under threat of losing their jobs, have been banned from discussing their research without political approval. Mentions of federal climate change research in the Canadian press have dropped 80 percent. The union that represents federal scientists and other professionals has, for the first time in its history, abandoned neutrality to campaign against Mr. Harper.

His active promotion of ignorance extends into the functions of government itself.


Most shockingly, he ended the mandatory long-form census, a decision protested by nearly 500 organizations in Canada, including the Canadian Medical Association, the Canadian Chamber of Commerce and the Canadian Catholic Council of Bishops. In the age of information, he has stripped Canada of its capacity to gather information about itself.

The Harper years have seen a subtle darkening of Canadian life.

2015 02 27 Harper election 2015, act 4 scene 1

The darkness has resulted, organically, in one of the most scandal-plagued administrations in Canadian history. Mr. Harper’s tenure coincided with the scandal of Rob Ford, the mayor of Toronto who admitted to smoking crack while in office and whose secret life came to light only when Gawker, an American website, broke the story. In a famous video at a Ford family barbecue, Mr. Harper praised the Fords as a “Conservative political dynasty.”

Mr. Harper’s appointments to the Senate — which in Canada is a mercifully impotent body employed strictly for political payoffs — have proved greedier than the norm. Mr. Harper’s chief of staff was forced out for paying off a senator who fudged his expenses. The Mounties have pressed criminal charges.

2013 Stephen Harper blames Nigel Wright for his flatulence

After the 2011 election, a Conservative staffer, Michael Sona, was convicted of using robocalls to send voters to the wrong polling places in Guelph, Ontario.


In the words of the judge, he was guilty of “callous and blatant disregard for the right of people to vote.”


In advance of this election, instead of such petty ploys, the Canadian Conservatives have passed the Fair Elections Act, a law with a classically Orwellian title, which not only needlessly tightens the requirements for voting but also has restricted the chief executive of Elections Canada from promoting the act of voting. Mr. Harper seems to think that his job is to prevent democracy.

2015 07 30 Harper killed democracy cartoon

But the worst of the Harper years is that all this secrecy and informational control have been at the service of no larger vision for the country. The policies that he has undertaken have been negligible — more irritating distractions than substantial changes.

harper prisons for poor and mentally ill

He is “tough on crime,” and so he has built more prisons at great expense at the exact moment when even American conservatives have realized that over-incarceration causes more problems than it solves. Then there is a new law that allows the government to revoke citizenship for dual citizens convicted of terrorism or high treason — effectively creating levels of Canadianness and problems where none existed.

dewar cartoon july 24 2013 col.jpg

dewar cartoon july 24 2013 col.jpg

For a man who insists on such intense control, the prime minister has not managed to control much that matters. The argument for all this secrecy was a technocratic impulse — he imagined Canada as a kind of Singapore, only more polite and rule abiding.

The major foreign policy goal of his tenure was the Keystone Pipeline, which Mr. Harper ultimately failed to deliver. The Canadian dollar has returned to the low levels that once earned it the title of the northern peso.

loonie rollercoaster by montreal simon

Image by Montreal Simon

Despite being left in a luxurious position of strength after the global recession, he coasted on what he knew: oil. In the run-up to the election, the Bank of Canada has announced that Canada just had two straight quarters of contraction — the technical definition of a recession.

He has been a poor manager by any metric.

2014-03-06-04-53-27-swastika cartoon canadian parliament

The early polls show Mr. Harper trailing, but he’s beaten bad polls before. He has been prime minister for nearly a decade for a reason: He promised a steady and quiet life, undisturbed by painful facts. The Harper years have not been terrible; they’ve just been bland and purposeless. Mr. Harper represents the politics of willful ignorance. It has its attractions.


Whether or not he loses, he will leave Canada more ignorant than he found it. The real question for the coming election is a simple but grand one: Do Canadians like their country like that?


A novelist and a columnist at Esquire Magazine who lives in Toronto. A version of this op-ed appears in print on August 16, 2015, on page SR7 of the National edition with the headline: The Closing of the Canadian Mind. [Emphasis added]

[Refer also to:

February 12, 2009: The Intimidation of Ernst A segment of Ernst presentation at Cochrane, Alberta, September 10, 2011

February 12, 2009: Following a CTV W5 National News segment of Ernst’s explosively contaminated well water and the ERCB’s (now AER, previously EUB) treatment of her, “undercover” Royal Canadian Mounted Police from Harper’s (Encana’s?) anti-terrorist squad arrive warrant-less at Jessica’s home in Rosebud to interrogate. EnCana, Alberta Environment and the ERCB had been served legal papers two months previously.

2009 02 12 Harper's anti-terrorist squad, warrantless, drop in on Ernst at home after W5 news show on her

2013 02 22: Fracking: Feds Throw Wrench in High Profile Lawsuit, Judge suddenly promoted; plaintiff Ernst sees strategy to ‘delay and exhaust.’

2013 03 11 Canada Fracked the Head off Lady Justice

2012: NEW BOARD GAME from Harper Brothers!

2015: Stephen Harper, Serial Abuser of Power: The Evidence

2015: Stephen Harper, Serial Abuser of Power: More Evidence

2015: Harper, Serial Abuser of Power: The Evidence Compiled

2015: Stephen Harper Is the Terrorist Canadians Should Most Fear 

By any definition of “terrorism,” Stephen Harper is the terrorist Canadians should most fear.

A secret police force, secret trials, and secret judicial decisions that limit your Charter rights, this is what Bill C-51 introduces to Canada.

harper-terrorist cartoon, just say no to harper in 2015

Bill C-51 is a legal bomb. It puts far more Canadians at risk than ISIS ever will. It’s designed to intimidate.

It’s easy to think you won’t be affected by this new law of terror, but you’re wrong. It’s broad enough to affect everyone.

They might not come for you at first, but, eventually, they will. History tell us that.

Let’s work together to build a chorus of opposition that delivers one clear message to all Canadians who care to listen: Just Say No To Harper in 2015.

This entry was posted in Global Frac News. Bookmark the permalink.